The Citistates Group presents

Regional Growth Futures: Getting It Right

Neal Peirce / Jul 16 2010

For Release Sunday, July 18th, 2010
© 2010 Washington Post Writers Group

Neal PeirceDoes it always take adversity to get an American region to “get its act together” in planning future growth?

The Puget Sound area anchored by Seattle suggests “no.” Geology and modern economics have blessed the region in astounding ways. There’s the natural legacy of glistening snow-capped mountain peaks and lush Douglas fir beside sparking watersides. Economically, the region’s had such world-renowned economic treasures as Boeing, Microsoft and Amazon.com, excellent ports and vibrant international trade.

Yet there’s been a dark underside to the region’s exuberant growth — to 4.7 million people — over the last decades. I vividly recall a 1989 helicopter ride marked by spectacular views of Mount Rainier, a rainbow at Snoqualmie Falls and picturesque villages. But I could also see bulldozed “progress” — a plethora of scarred hilltops, deep cuts into the magnificent evergreen tapestry.

Over the past 30 years, more than 2 million acres of Cascade-range forest and farm land has given way to sprawling development. In 1990 the state of Washington did pass a growth management act that restrained some helter-skelter expansion. But development has fragmented open spaces, including wildlife habitat and corridors. With rapid expansion of the urban footprint, added paving has intensified flooding and erosion. There’s concern that climate change will bring warmer winters with less snow pack, leading to summertime drought, water shortages and increased forest fire danger.

Responding to the dangers, a “Cascade Agenda” was launched in 2005 — a 100-year conservation and preservation plan for 1.3 million acres of the Puget Sound region’s most prized waters, mountains and communities. Some 225,000 private acres have already been conserved under the plan, which is rooted in an imaginative transfer of development rights.

But there’s concern that 700,000 acres of working farmland is being converted to 10- and even 80-acre residential lots, translating to some 18,000 housing units over time. So there’s a new community discussion with city managers, focused on where new development should be channeled, says Gene Duvernot, Cascade Land Conservancy president. The draft legislation would give the Puget Sound Regional Council authority to apportion the 18,000 housing units across the cities, granting them tax increment authority so that new development goes “up” in the existing towns rather than “spread” across the landscape.

But the process isn’t “anti-development,” Duvernoy insists, because developers, in the process, can still have a “product” — just producing it in towns and cities rather than in the form of outward sprawl. “Great communities, great landscape, a sustainable environment — they can only work in tandem,” he insists. “Built right, attractive, affordable city neighborhoods will be our best hope.”

Regional leaders are now using the language of “ecodistricts” –chains of communities that feature not just low-impact development techniques and a range of housing types and costs but also frequent public transit, high efficiency district energy systems, and community space. The initiatives are all part of a package it’s hoped will show distinctive region-wide collaboration and innovation, qualifying the area for support under the federal government’s new Sustainable Communities grant program.

It seems the Cascade Land Conservancy’s agenda is never complete. A top example– restoring neglected parks to their former glory. Seattle and four neighboring communities have joined a “Green Cities” program for massive, city-wide park and open space restoration. Some 10,000 volunteers are involved. “It may be decades before we are all done. But it’s a far better investment in a city’s quality of life to restore a weed-choked park than purchase new land,” notes Duvernoy.

And now, to match the Cascade Agenda, the Conservancy has organized an Olympic Agenda to cover Puget Sound’s western neighbor — the entire Olympic Peninsula, which offers some of North America’s most dramatic scenery, ranging from glacier-rich Mount Olympus to thick canopies of rain forest. Yet the collapse of the timber industry has hit hard, while farming and fishing aren’t providing the jobs they once did. Unemployment is high.

Meanwhile, the peninsula is under economic pressure to fragment and convert private lands for private real estate development, raising dangers for both its rough-and-ready rural character and its pristine shorelines and estuaries. Proposed remedies have emerged in county-by-county dialogues that the Conservancy has organized. They range from rounding up capital to replace worn-out bridges and water systems to “green” infrastructure in the form of community-based forests and well-maintained trails to undergird both community life and tourism.

The extension of regional dialogue from the Everett-Seattle/Bellevue-Tacoma axis to the neighboring Olympic Peninsula, from urban to rural, from income-rich to economically struggling territory, isn’t totally unique in the U.S. But it’s rare, and it represents the kind of imaginative citistate-wide approaches that the times demand. Hard to quantify in the short-term, the benefits of thinking, planning, strategizing together, jointly exploring innovations and promising steps for the future, could in time be dramatic. More American regions should be emulating the model.


Neal Peirce’s e-mail is npeirce@citistates.com.

For reprints of Neal Peirce’s column, please contact Washington Post Permissions, c/o PARS International Corp., WPPermissions@parsintl.com, fax 212-221-9195. For newspaper syndication sales, Washington Post Writers Group, 202-334-5375, wpwgsales@washpost.com.

2 Comments

  1. Dee
    Posted July 19, 2010 at 11:57 am | Permalink

    Mr. Pierce …
    Have you forgotten the “model” set by The Nature Conservancy in your neighborhood several years ago?
    We haven’t.
    Too bad you didn’t take the time to interview some average citizens in the Seattle area. Gene Duvernoy’s for-profit connections in Washington State are legendary. Conservation is merely a smokescreen for landowners and venture capitalists looking for one more way to make a buck.
    Dee

  2. Bill Bradburd
    Posted July 21, 2010 at 3:36 pm | Permalink

    The issue for Seattle is that growth is not balanced with concurrent delivery of transit, open space and other urban amenities.

    Developers get a free ride here with no impact fees and a development agenda that prioritizes density over the other dimensions of that produce a quality urban experience. Therefore we are experiencing a decrease in tree canopy, decreasing permeable surfaces (yielding more polluted storm water run-off into the Puget Sound), increasing road congestion (yielding air quality impacts, complicating a desire for more biking), and an inability to support our crumbling infrastructure or keep our parks and libraries open.

    In the same way the that the countryside is despoiled by uncontrolled growth, the urban fabric can be destroyed as well. Our vision of walkable, complete communities is still out of reach.

    The fallacy of Vision 2040 is that by packing growth into the two major cities – Seattle and Bellevue – is that somehow we are going to save the hinterlands. But development patterns belie that myth. More importantly, the continued growth of the downtown Seattle – where 60% of the workers come from outside of the city – requires more massive investments in the freeways and light rail to move these people from the outlying areas to the office towers. I suspect conditions are similar for Bellevue.

    We need to recognize that balanced development – looking to towns like Federal Way, Issaquah, Kirkland, Renton, Bothell, etc, etc to accept growth. With new-urbanism constructs these all can become vibrant cities and not just be bedroom communities for the two queens. These will be the ecodistricts of the future and provide the best opportunity to help solve our growth and financial problems at the same time.

Post a Comment

Connect with Facebook

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*