For Release Sunday, December 25, 2011
© 2011 Washington Post Writers Group
A heartening sign of Christmas, 2011: holiday festival markets are emerging and flourishing in and near central city squares across America, smartly following the model of the great Christmas markets of Germany and other European lands.
The biggest and possibly most spectacular may be Union Square in New York, where over 100 merchants have been on hand this season offering delights ranging from hand-blown glass housewares to hand-tooled leather belts to “German delights … sweet and savory treats, cider and cappucinno to keep you warm.” A strong runner-up: New York’s Bryant Park, with dozens of stands.
But when I queried David Downey of the International Downtown Assn. about other cities, he e-mailed his member list and in hours was flooding my in-box with examples spread across the continent.
Rochester, Minn., for example, has “Market Strasse — our attempt to be an authentic German winter market.” Downtown Lancaster, Pa., created space for 20 local “creatives” to show their products. Kirkwood, Mo., turned its farmers’ market into a “Christmas Market & Gingerbread Shoppe.” The Roanoke, Va., “Dickens of Christmas” event has featured handmade crafts, soaps, and photography.
In Ohio, the Downtown Akron Partnership’s eight-year old Holiday Market, “begun in honor of German Christkindl Markets,” this year actually had two vendors hailing “from our Sister City of Chemnitz, Germany.” Missoula, Mont. — where I’ve repeatedly admired one of America’s finest all-seasons farmers’ and crafts markets — reported that the “Missoula Made Fair was so busy last Sunday you could barely get through the crowd!”
Parallel stories flooded in from Boston, Chicago, Baltimore and Dallas as well as Green Bay, Wis., Delray Beach, Fla., Albany, N.Y., Grand Rapids, Mich., Fort Collins, Colo., Charleston, S.C., Raleigh, N.C., even from Charlottetown, on Prince Edward Island in Canada.
There’s also some great news in Washington, D.C. (where normal life continues, notwithstanding the constant political calumny). A resplendant Downtown Holiday Market, which sprang up in a parking lot a few seasons ago, has graduated to a prime location directly beside the Smithsonian American Art Museum and National Portrait Gallery.

Nancy Wasserman, handcrafter of glass jewelry, displays her work at the D.C. Holiday Market
And it symbolizes an historic comeback. The market is located on the very stretch of Washington’s Seventh Street Northwest where I recall witnessing the tower of smoke rise from rioting and fires of the April 1968 weekend following the assassination of Martin Luther King, Jr. Decades of abandonment followed, but now the area — dubbed the new “Penn Quarter” — is alive with new shops, restaurants, a state-of-the-art sports arena and two Metro subway stops.
The D.C. Holiday Market was launched by Washington’s Business Improvement District, founded in 1977. BIDs — there are now about 1,200 across the U.S. — typically assesses all property owners and then provide special security, extra street cleaning, marketing and planning. The idea’s to match what malls offer — and more. Washington’s is one of the most successful, having in 14 years helped spark $14 billion worth of office, retail and residential growth. And with a special focus, as Richard Bradley, the BID’s founder and executive director puts it, on enriching street life, “populating the public space with art, commerce and sociability.”
Streets for people — not just “throughput” of motor vehicles — is the key concept. In earlier years, it took a Washington cafe owner up to two years to get a permit to place seats on the sidewalk outside his premise. “Today we’re up to 1,237 cafes with 3,800 seats– a true indicator of livability,” Bradley claims.
Wintertime livability is another challenge. America’s holiday markets may never equal Europe’s winter markets — cities like Vienna, Salzburg, Munich, Stuttgart and Strasbourg, where people flock by the tens of thousands, from late morning into the icy evenings, enjoying city blocks set aside for artisans’ stands, puppet shows, candies and gingerbread houses, miniature steam train rides, hot spiced gluhwein and much more.
But we’re learning. I checked with Michael Berman, whose D.C.-based Diverse Markets Management firm works extensively managing outdoor public exhibitor markets including the Downtown Holiday Market for Washington’s BID. Berman circulates word of the opportunity to display to over 1,000 exhibitors — independent painters, sculptors, fiber art, leather, glass, ceramic, jewelry, printmaking and speciality food specialists. Exhibitors of foreign crafts are also invited.
Then Berman assembles juries — art professionals “with a keen eye” — to decide which exhibitors have the class and originality to be invited. Each day there’s a slightly different mix, selected for optimum balance. And a big part of the enjoyment, walking from stall to stall, is to meet, talk with the designer/exhibitors. Suddenly one’s in dialogue with real humans about their creative work, and can buy from them directly — a rare luxury in the age of mass merchandizing.
Thinking jealously of Europe, Berman adds “Just one thing’s missing for us in winter — alcohol.” Licensing for outdoor shows is a challenge, he notes — but adds: “Just wait — Some year we will have a grog tent.”
Neal Peirce’s e-mail is npeirce@citistates.com.
For reprints of Neal Peirce’s column, please contact Washington Post Permissions, c/o PARS International Corp., WPPermissions@parsintl.com, fax 212-221-9195. For newspaper syndication sales, Washington Post Writers Group, 202-334-5375, wpwgsales@washpost.com.
4 Comments
Neal, At the risk of sounding self-serving, there’s one element of the European markets that seldom shows up in these downtown-sponsored artisan markets — flowers! Americans just don’t populate their homes with lots of flowers, although they do buy a few at the check-out counter of food supermarkets. Cost? Maybe it’s the major deterrent, although I don’t think so — I believe puritanical Americans have been so trained to spend their wealth only on long-lasting “things” that the joys of the moment are of less importance than obtaining long-term value. Hence the popularity of carnations! Anyway, glad you’ve focused on the idea of downtown markets — imaginative thinking for story ideas is what we’ve come to expect from Neal!! Have a happy Christmastime!
Neal, I am struck by how almost all the examples and the photos in your excellent collumn are of the arts. Whether craft, or visual art, or performance, much of what makes up these great holiday markets is what comes from the hands of artists and the extensive arts industry in America. In Europe the markets I have seen have a similar arts base. The American arts industry quietly but very substantially contributes to the US economy as you well know. I am urging our arts industry to be a little less quiet about this contribution. Thanks for your good work.
Comment from Jackie Hollis in Richmond, Va:
I noticed the Chris Kindl Markt in Nurnberg, Deutschland was not mentioned in your article which appeared in our local newspaper – (Richmond Times Dispatch –Va.). I am surprised since it is listed a probably the largest or nearly so in Europe.
When we moved to Germany to live for a time, it was one of the first places our family went to spend the better part of the first week of December. This year, there were approximately 3 + million people there during the month of Thanksgiving Eve through Christmas Eve. The market has over 200 ‘stalls,’ I believe, from countries all over. It began so many centuries’ ago, historians are not sure of the date.
Just thought you might want to add this to your ‘archives’ for history’s sake.
Blessed 2012!
Wow! What an honor to be included on this informative article. The most important factor, (besides logistics, advertising and venue, of course) is that the vendors are conscious to provide an upbeat experience for the visitors. This will assure repeat attendance and “spreading the word”.
Thru the hard work of Michael and his staff, the Market has grown each year and D.C. celebrates this lively event.